What do I turn off first, the water or the power?
Close the cold water inlet valve on top of the tank first, because that stops the supply feeding the leak. Then cut the energy: the breaker for an electric heater, or the gas control to off. Do not step onto a wet floor near an outlet or appliance until power to that area is off.
If the inlet valve is seized, and on an older tank it often is, go to the main shut-off for the house instead. Do not open the tank's drain valve to empty it onto the floor you are trying to save, and do not touch the temperature and pressure relief valve: the discharge is near boiling. A gas heater's control dial turns to off without any need to touch the gas line itself.
Then stop using water in the house and start the clock on drying rather than on the replacement. The longer water sits in carpet pad, under a closet threshold or on a crawl-space barrier, the more material moves from dryable to removable.
Why does where the heater sits decide how bad it gets?
Because water runs downhill and finds floor assemblies. A closet heater soaks hallway flooring and the wall plate; a garage unit mostly stays on slab; an attic platform sends water into the ceiling below; and a crawl-space tank wets insulation, ducts and the subfloor over clay that will not drain.
The hall or laundry closet is the most common and the most expensive per gallon, because the water goes straight onto finished floor. Hardwood cups, laminate swells at the seams and water wicks under the threshold into rooms either side. The wall behind the tank gets it too, which is why drywall often comes out at the base even when the floor is the visible damage.
Attic and crawl-space installations hide the loss instead. An attic leak appears as a ceiling stain in a room with no plumbing in it, and in a crawl space the water sits on the vapor barrier, soaks batt insulation into a sagging mat and wets the underside of the subfloor. Both need equipment in the space itself, and the crawl-space version often pairs with crawl space water damage work.
Can carpet, hardwood and crawl-space insulation be saved?
Carpet often yes, the pad under it usually not, solid hardwood frequently yes with the right method, and soaked insulation almost never. The deciding factors are how clean the water was, how long it sat and whether the material can be dried from both sides.
Water from a failed tank starts out reasonably clean, which is the one piece of good news. It picks up rust and sediment on the way out and it degrades as it sits, so the same loss handled on day one and on day four is not the same job. Carpet pad is a sponge and comes out as a matter of course; the carpet itself can often be lifted, dried and re-laid.
Solid hardwood is worth the effort. Drying mats pull air down through the boards, and a cupped floor is left to settle before anyone considers sanding. Engineered and laminate flooring that has swollen at the edges does not come back. Wet batt insulation, whether in a closet wall or a crawl space, is bagged out because it holds water against framing and no longer insulates once it has been soaked.
Who does which part, and does the city need a permit?
A licensed plumber handles the heater, the relief valve, the pan and the drain line, because plumbing always needs a specialty trade license in Georgia. The restoration crew extracts and dries. Permits depend on the work and the address, and inside the city they come through the Office of Buildings.
Inside Atlanta, permits are filed with the City of Atlanta Office of Buildings through its Accela portal, and a plumbing permit is required to replace freeze-damaged or leaking concealed piping where the new run exceeds five feet. Outside the city it varies: Sandy Springs, Smyrna and Mableton run their own building departments, and DeKalb, Cobb, Clayton and Douglas handle unincorporated areas. Confirm per address rather than assuming.
On the rebuild side, Georgia generally requires a state license for residential work valued at $2,500 or more, through the State Licensing Board for Residential and Commercial General Contractors under the Secretary of State, and the board publishes a license lookup. Plumbing, electrical and conditioned-air work needs its own specialty license regardless of value.
What makes a tank fail here, and what cuts the odds of the next one?
Age, sediment and a spent anode rod account for most failures, with pressure and a missing expansion tank behind the rest. The practical defenses are a pan plumbed to a real drain, an annual flush, replacing the supply connectors when the heater is replaced, and a leak alarm on the floor.
Sediment collects on the bottom of a tank, insulates the steel from the water above it and drives local overheating, which is what the rumbling noise is telling you. The anode rod is a sacrificial piece of metal that corrodes so the tank does not; once it is gone the tank is next. A thermal expansion tank keeps pressure spikes from loading the vessel and the relief valve. None of this is exotic and all of it is a plumber's annual visit.
Add the local wrinkle: a heater or its lines in an unheated crawl space, attic or garage is exposed in a cold snap. Freezes are not frequent here, with roughly 40 nights a year below freezing and a January average low near 32 degrees, and houses in this climate are often built without the pipe protection a cold-climate house takes for granted. The January 2025 and January 2026 cold snaps broke water mains around the city, and the same weather splits unprotected supply lines. The older Atlanta plumbing guide covers what tends to go first in each era of house.